Welcome, it will depend on which company is guaranteeing the signature. If its one of the good ones like JSA then you should be ok if it's not a well known company then personally I would steer clear. The COA will only relate to the signature, these players will sign anything so it's no guarantee that the jersey is a genuine jersey, in fact 99% of signed jerseys are counterfeit and you have to be real careful about the autographs too as most are fakes too.